PART 2 – The Detective Played My Ex-Husband’s Recorded Phone Call, and I Finally Understood Why My Children Could Not Escape His Apartment

I didn't want to leave the hospital.

That was the first thing I told Detective Brennan.

My sons were still being treated.

My daughter was exhausted.

And every instinct I had told me to stay where my children could reach me.

"I can't go anywhere right now."

Brennan didn't argue.

He looked toward the treatment rooms.

"I understand."

I glanced through the small window in the door.

People were moving around a hospital bed.

I couldn't see which twin was inside.

That frightened me more than I wanted to admit.

"Why do you need me at the hotel?"

"We're trying to establish exactly what happened."

"Then bring Russell here."

Brennan paused.

"We're working on that."

I didn't like his answer.

It sounded careful.

I had heard enough careful answers from Russell during our marriage.

I was tired of them.

Before I could say anything else, Dr. Okonkwo came into the hallway.

He had been overseeing the twins' treatment.

I knew him well enough by then to recognize when he was concerned.

But he didn't look defeated.

That mattered.

"Joanna, we're continuing to stabilize both boys."

I stepped toward him.

"Are they going to survive?"

He didn't offer an easy promise.

"They're getting the care they need. We have them under close observation."

I nodded.

I wanted a different answer.

One that started with yes and ended there.

But I knew medicine didn't always work that way.

"What about Piper?"

"She's receiving fluids, and the staff will monitor her closely."

I looked down at my hands.

There was dried blood near my thumb.

A nurse had placed a small bandage over the cut from the emergency cabinet.

I hadn't even thanked her.

"I don't want them waking up and finding me gone."

Dr. Okonkwo glanced toward Brennan.

Then he looked directly at me.

"We'll take care of them while you speak with the detective."

I rubbed my forehead.

"They've already been left alone."

"I know."

He didn't say anything else.

He didn't need to.

I went to Piper's bedside before leaving.

She was sleeping deeply.

Her face looked less strained than it had in the apartment.

I touched the edge of her blanket.

I wanted to wake her and explain where I was going.

But she needed sleep.

So I told the nurse.

"If she asks for me, please tell her I'll come back."

The nurse nodded.

"I will."

I stood there a few seconds longer.

Then I went with Brennan.

Outside, Chicago looked ordinary.

Cars moved through intersections.

People waited for buses.

A couple walked past the hospital carrying paper cups of coffee.

I remember being angry at them for looking so normal.

My family had nearly been destroyed.

And the world was continuing as if nothing had happened.

Brennan's vehicle was parked near the entrance.

It was an unmarked police car.

I climbed into the back.

He sat in front.

There was a small laptop positioned near the center console.

A Panasonic.

I noticed the name because Russell once owned one like it.

He liked expensive equipment.

He believed expensive equipment made people take him seriously.

Brennan started the car.

For a while, neither of us spoke.

I watched the city through the window.

Every dark doorway reminded me of Unit 4B.

Every closed blind made me think of Piper.

Eventually, I asked the question that had been bothering me since the hospital.

"Did he know they were there?"

Brennan looked at me in the rearview mirror.

"We're reviewing that."

"He's their father."

"I understand."

"He was supposed to be watching them."

"I know."

I leaned back against the seat.

"I need you to tell me something."

He waited.

"Was he actually staying at that hotel?"

"Yes."

"The whole time?"

"We have evidence placing him there during the period we're investigating."

I looked at my hands again.

I kept seeing Piper's plastic cup.

The dirty rim.

The way she held it with both hands.

She had been saving water for her brothers.

Or trying to.

I had never asked her to do anything like that.

I wondered how many times she had tried before calling me.

Brennan slowed for a traffic light.

Then he opened the laptop.

"I want to explain what we've found so far."

I sat forward.

He turned the screen enough for me to see.

There were records displayed in rows.

Dates.

Times.

Account details.

I couldn't read everything from where I sat.

"What is that?"

"Records connected to Russell's apartment."

I looked at him.

"Electricity?"

"Among other things."

I remembered the message on my phone.

Friday.

Six in the evening.

At the customer's request.

"I showed the officer the notice."

"Yes. That helped us establish the timeline."

"Was the bill overdue?"

"No."

I stared at him.

"What?"

"The service wasn't stopped for nonpayment."

I had expected that answer to make me feel better.

It didn't.

"Then why was it stopped?"

Brennan rested one hand near the laptop.

"Russell contacted the provider."

I looked down at my phone.

I opened the notification again.

The same words were still there.

I had read them in the hallway while holding both babies.

At the customer's request.

I had been too frightened to think through their meaning.

Now there was no emergency to distract me from them.

"You mean he called the company himself?"

"That's what the records show."

"Why?"

Brennan didn't answer immediately.

Instead, he reached into the front compartment and brought out a small earpiece.

"We have a recording of that conversation."

I looked at it.

A little black device.

Nothing special.

Something I might have used at work.

But I didn't want to touch it.

"Is it really Russell?"

"You'll recognize his voice."

I took the earpiece.

My fingers were clumsy.

I almost dropped it.

Brennan waited while I placed it against my ear.

"Tell me when you're ready."

I wanted to say I wasn't.

I wanted to go back to the hospital and sit beside the twins.

But I couldn't keep wondering what Russell had done.

"Play it."

There was a brief electronic sound.

Then I heard the voice of a customer service employee.

She introduced the company and asked how she could help.

A man's voice answered.

Russell.

I recognized him immediately.

He wasn't angry.

He wasn't confused.

He wasn't upset about a bill.

He sounded the way he did when ordering something over the phone.

Polite.

Confident.

Completely relaxed.

He told the woman he wanted the electricity disconnected from Unit 4B.

As soon as possible.

I leaned forward.

He gave the account information.

Confirmed the apartment number.

Then told her nobody would be living there for approximately a week.

Nobody.

I felt my stomach turn.

Piper was there.

Silas was there.

Theo was there.

His own children.

The woman asked a question about the connected systems in the apartment.

I listened as Russell acknowledged that he understood.

He knew the locks depended on electricity.

He knew the window coverings were powered.

He knew other functions would stop working.

Then he confirmed the shutoff time.

Six o'clock that evening.

I could hear him breathing between sentences.

Calm.

Patient.

As though he had all the time in the world.

The recording ended.

I didn't move.

Brennan gave me a moment.

I kept staring at the back of his seat.

There was a small mark near the headrest.

I focused on it because I couldn't focus on anything else.

"He knew."

My voice sounded strange.

Brennan said nothing.

"He knew the apartment would stop working."

"Yes."

I pressed my fingers against my forehead.

"He told them it was empty."

"That's what he said."

"But it wasn't empty."

"No."

I looked up.

"His children were inside."

Brennan met my eyes in the mirror.

"Yes, Joanna."

I took the earpiece out.

My hand was shaking.

For several seconds, I couldn't bring myself to put it down.

I remembered the day Russell first showed me his new apartment.

He had been proud of it.

He walked from room to room touching panels and demonstrating what they controlled.

He showed me how the lights could change from his phone.

How the blinds could close together.

How the door could lock with a command.

He even showed me the backup locking feature.

I remembered asking why everything had to be so complicated.

He laughed.

He said the apartment was designed for security.

I hadn't liked that answer.

But I also hadn't imagined anyone using those features against a child.

"That lock," I said.

Brennan waited.

"When the electricity went out, the lock couldn't be opened normally."

"That's consistent with what investigators found."

I thought of the dead keypad.

I had entered Russell's code again and again.

Nothing.

I had needed a fire extinguisher to force my way inside.

An eight-year-old child couldn't have done that.

Piper probably couldn't even have lifted the extinguisher.

"He knew she couldn't get out."

Brennan looked toward me.

"The system's behavior was explained during the call."

I swallowed.

"And the blinds?"

"They were dependent on the same electrical supply."

I remembered stepping inside the apartment.

The darkness had been so complete that I couldn't immediately see my daughter.

The windows were covered.

The rooms were overheated.

There was no air moving.

The refrigerator had stopped cooling.

Food had spoiled.

And the apartment had become a place where three children couldn't care for themselves.

Russell had paid a great deal of money for that building.

He had bragged about how comfortable it was.

He had told the custody judge the children would have everything they needed there.

I remembered that hearing.

He had described the apartment in detail.

The separate rooms.

The security systems.

The controlled temperature.

He had made it sound safer than my house.

I had almost believed him.

"He knew all of it," I said.

Brennan didn't interrupt.

"He knew the door wouldn't work. He knew the air-conditioning would stop. He knew the fridge would go warm."

I stopped.

There was something I couldn't bring myself to finish.

Piper had been alone with two babies.

The water had stopped running properly.

The apartment had become unbearably hot.

And Russell had described it as vacant.

I pictured him sitting somewhere with his phone.

Three blocks away.

Perhaps eating dinner.

Perhaps watching television.

Perhaps sleeping in a clean hotel bed.

While his daughter tried to keep her brothers awake.

I pressed the heels of my hands against my eyes.

I couldn't cry.

Not yet.

My anger had pushed everything else aside.

"I thought he forgot about them."

Brennan said nothing.

"I thought maybe something happened at work."

I looked up.

"I kept trying to make an excuse for him."

That was difficult to admit.

Russell and I had been divorced for years.

I knew he could be selfish.

I knew he cared too much about how other people saw him.

I knew he could make a terrible decision and then blame the person who noticed.

But I had still believed there was a line he would never cross.

Our children.

I thought that line existed.

I had been wrong.

I remembered our separation.

Russell had never accepted that a marriage could end without someone winning.

He kept records of small disagreements.

He saved messages.

He brought up things I had said months earlier and insisted they proved something about my character.

He treated every exchange like evidence.

If I arrived five minutes late for pickup, he mentioned it.

If I asked to change a weekend, he called it interference.

If Piper cried after visiting him, he accused me of encouraging her.

I had spent years trying to make the situation less difficult for the children.

I thought cooperation would eventually calm him down.

Sometimes I even apologized when I hadn't done anything wrong.

Because I wanted peace.

That word makes me ashamed now.

Peace.

I had mistaken my silence for peace.

Brennan's voice brought me back.

"Joanna, I need you to think about what Russell knew."

I looked at him.

"He knew I was away."

"Yes."

"He knew the children were supposed to be with him."

"Yes."

"And he knew what would happen when the power was cut."

Brennan nodded.

I thought about my nursing course in Milwaukee.

The course had been required for an additional certification.

I had made arrangements weeks in advance.

Russell knew exactly when I would be away.

He knew I couldn't simply walk into the apartment whenever I wanted.

He had insisted on taking the children himself.

He had even made a point of telling me he didn't need help.

I remembered him saying that he could handle his own children.

I had wanted to believe him.

The judge had wanted proof.

That was why the arrangement existed.

Not because Russell had suddenly become interested in changing diapers or preparing bottles.

Because he wanted something from the custody process.

I turned toward Brennan.

"Did he tell anyone why he wanted the power shut off?"

"We're still examining the evidence."

"What evidence?"

"Financial records. Communications. Information from the hotel."

I looked through the windshield.

Traffic had started moving again.

Brennan drove toward the hotel.

I recognized the neighborhood.

Russell's apartment was nearby.

I knew the streets because I had driven them for every pickup and drop-off.

There was a bakery on one corner.

A pharmacy across the road.

A restaurant where Russell once took me for our anniversary.

Ordinary places.

And somewhere among them, he had been staying while our children suffered.

I thought of the utility employee on the recording.

She had asked him whether he understood the consequences of the disconnection.

He had said he did.

That detail stayed with me.

Someone had given him an opportunity to reconsider.

Someone had explained that his apartment's systems would stop working.

He had heard the warning.

And he continued.

I leaned forward.

"Detective, why would someone do that?"

Brennan kept his eyes on the road.

"That's what we're trying to establish."

"No. I mean, why would a father deliberately make his own home unsafe while his children were inside?"

He didn't answer.

I looked down at the earpiece in my hand.

Such a small thing.

It had carried Russell's voice into my ear.

And in less than a minute, that voice had destroyed the last excuse I was willing to make for him.

I handed it back.

"I need you to find out why."

Brennan accepted it.

"We intend to."

I watched the buildings pass.

Then I spoke again.

"He didn't just leave them."

Brennan glanced at me.

"He made sure they couldn't leave."

Saying it aloud was different from thinking it.

It sounded too terrible to belong to my life.

But the evidence was there.

The recorded request.

The disabled lock.

The sealed blinds.

The silent ventilation.

And three children who had been left to endure the result.

I had gone to Unit 4B believing Russell had failed as a parent.

Now I understood that he had taken deliberate steps to create the conditions I found.

I still didn't know what he hoped to gain.

But I no longer believed any part of it had happened by accident.


Click here to continue reading: PART 3: Nine Days Before Our Custody Hearing, the Detective Uncovered the Plan My Ex-Husband Had Built Around My Children’s Suffering

Story Parts

My Eight-Year-Old Daughter Called Me From Her Father’s Apartment, and What I Found Behind His Locked Door Changed Everything I Believed

Part 2 of 5

Previous: Part 1
Next: Part 3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *